My major challenge with calculus is confidence. For whatever reason, the AP Exam causes our students to freak out. I have a number of ideas to try and fight this that will trickle out here as the year progresses. One of them is to teach them how to use resources. And second, provide them with resources that are going to mirror the instruction they're given in class. Meaning, sending them to instructional videos by some random guy on YouTube is not involved here.

To start, I want to work any homework assignments I give them. I got a special notebook for it and everything. Then I thought, well, these should be available to them. But borrowing the notebook only helps one kid at a time. Five minutes of fiddling with Dropbox later and I created my Calculus share folder:

I post the solutions around the time I give the assignment. We have several conversations in class about the right and wrong way to use solutions. Homework is such a tiny part of their grade, the lack of understanding that will come out on tests isn't worth it. Most understand that attempting it themselves is the appropriate thing to do. In fact, one kid found an error in MY work, which was cool.

That last one might scare you. Hold on, that's the TEST ANSWER KEY? Are you crazy? No. The AP Exam is the final performance. I gain nothing by giving them assessments that they can't learn from. ALL their skills have to be sharp in 8 months. If I can't get them into an analysis and growth mindset now, they'll never convince themselves they can study for something like an AP Exam next semester. Their tests are short and frequent. Material on them overlaps. Once something appears on a test, it can appear again WHENEVER. I'm asking you limit questions in March, kids. Making old assessment part of their preparation routine is something I see that can fight the confidence problem. I might have messed up, but darn it I'll be ready the next time.

As you read this they'll be taking Test 2. I'm cautiously optimistic that some of them see a value in this opportunity.

AuthorJonathan Claydon
4 CommentsPost a comment

Help me out here, Algebra II people, we have a problem.

The answer I'm looking for, is "where does the given parabola intersect the line y = 7?"

One of the first things I decided to cover in Pre-Cal this year was solving quadratic equations. It creeps up on you in Calculus and beyond that I don't want my students to wait until they're 22 to realize its value like I did.

When I introduced the topic, I asked "why do quadratics have two solutions?" In every class someone suggested it had something to do with the x-axis. I pushed and wondered "what's your obsession with the x-axis?"

I tried to confront this problem last year with my method for introducing the quadratic formula. Students saw the quadratic formula only as a means for finding x-intercepts. They are not totally wrong, but they don't know the truth.

Part of this is the fault of textbooks. As I noticed last year, there is an obsession with giving students quadratics that are equal to 0 and equating roots, solutions, and zeros as like terms. When really, what they need to understand, is you can construct a quadratic which in turn has x-intercepts that are equivalent to the intersection (or lack thereof) of the starting expressions.

Compounding the problem is then showing them half a dozen methods for solving, muddying the waters the whole way. Should I factor? Should I complete the square? What about this formula thing? Students have no idea where to start. Every class admitted this to me. All of them could tease out factoring and the quadratic formula as methods, but very few could describe when one is more desirable.

I'd love to admit that my returning Pivot students nailed this question like they should have, but that wasn't true.

The traditional treatment of quadratics and what the two solutions represent does more harm than you think.

AuthorJonathan Claydon
2 CommentsPost a comment

In January 2011, I tried something crazy. It's now a local phenomenon.

I had a mind blowing meeting with a group of middle school teachers a couple weeks ago. A group ready to change just about everything they do regarding student work management and assessment. Not just ready, but determined.

I began to seriously look at my assessment practices almost four years ago. Really, it was a time concern. I spent my first year giving big unit tests and grading homework and all that stuff they say you're supposed to do and found it incompatible with the demands on my time from coaching. By accident, I wandered into SBG, notebooks and all that. Three years ago, I started sharing my successes with my math department. Two years ago, many of them were ready to try it.

And now, years after a secret experiment, SBG and notebooks is the majority practice at all levels of math in my school, Algebra 1 to Calculus. We've all implemented it differently, PreAP is excluded for the most part (though not mine), our notebook management systems are varied, and I will say that not everyone may experience the same altering side effects I did, but we made a change.

Even crazier, in just a handful of meetings, an entire middle school hopped on board because many of my colleagues had experienced such positive results and testified as much to them. At some distant point in the future, there's a kid who will graduate having spent their 6th - 12th math career judged by how they show growth.

Challenges remain:

  • SBG is no bandaid for bad lessons, learning to be interesting is a whole other hurdle
  • this middle school is in uncharted territory, with no one specifically on campus who has implemented this stuff before
  • our Algebra 1 team is trying SBG, notebooks, AND a tweaked curriculum, there will be kinks, but my role this year is their direct line of support
  • new teachers are always a tough sell, never getting the full philosophy behind the move or experiencing the classroom challenges that lead to this stuff in the first place
  • SBG and notebooks can't be forced as a matter of policy, it will guarantee half-hearted implementation, each teacher needs the eureka moment, and that may never come

We aren't perfect. It is not math department heaven on earth. Simple requiring a student to have a notebook does not mean you will have 100% engagement. Implementing SBG will not guarantee you have a 0% failure rate or that kids will achieve that understanding they've seemed to be missing.

The point of this is to say that change is possible. Change at scale is possible. And it happened organically. Our district did not mandate any of these policies. There is a ton of work to do. But the fact that we even have these discussions locally without anyone thinking I'm a crazy person is important.

If you have great practices that are working for you, you don't have to be the lone voice in the wilderness. Student results speak for themselves. Chances are there's a teacher in your district who wish things could be better but doesn't know where to start. Show them what to do. Share everything. And slowly, you can convince a lot of people to step back at their current methods and ask "why?"

AuthorJonathan Claydon

This is year six. I've taught academic (on level) classes for every year prior. It's what I know, and what I really enjoyed. Last year I took a random assortment of on level kids on a crazy experiment and they blew me away.

The world is different now. In what started as a quest to attempt Pivot Algebra II on a single PreAP class, I'm now knee deep in AP and PreAP. I have 154 students in 5 classes (2 Calc, 3 PreCal). The first week was, strange.

  • PreCal numbers are 34, 36, 36, the largest classes I've ever taught, and yet the size has not been a problem
  • despite the giant size, every PreCal class exhibits laser focus when requested
  • upon my encouragement, 8 of my on level kids from Algebra II signed up for the PreAP experience, they hold their own and are teaching the PreAP lifers around them how to do stuff, I almost cried when one suggested something might be failing due to the presence of complex numbers
  • Calculus students who had me for on level Pre Cal shared in my amazement at how quiet my classroom can be when it's time for business while the lifers looked at them strange "what do you mean, class was loud?"
  • said Calculus students who had me for on level almost disowned me when I told them homework was a regular part of an AP class
  • secretly, I don't care for the whole PreAP distinction and don't use it on tests or my objectives area, I think that designation gets corrupted by teachers who use it as at excuse for bad teaching, excessive homework, and general "this is what it's like in COLLEGE" bullcrap
  • my in class support is far more advanced, WAY fewer students need help getting started on classwork, and anyone with a question starts it with "well this is what I tried and I THINK this the problem but SHE says it could be..." while I get a little wide-eyed and then examine their work
  • in but two sessions of classwork, I've already settled half a dozen PreCal arguments about equation solving methods, with both parties having strong cases
  • in those two sessions of PreCal classwork, out of nowhere someone would ask "so it's homework if we don't finish, right?" as I had to take pause and then say "no, that's not really my thing"
  • the students were totally ok if they ran into something weird on an assignment and there wasn't an exact example to follow

Classroom Management wise, it's like we're closer to Columbus Day than Labor Day. I'm not totally used to this yet. The thing that makes me excited though, is finding ways to step up my own game and challenge them in ways they haven't seen before. Already, applying what I learned from the Pivot project is going well. I helped stamp out the misconception that quadratic solutions ALWAYS involve the x-axis.

I'm liking it here in bizarro world.

AuthorJonathan Claydon

At TMC14 the entertaining Steve Leinwand gave a talk about some of the trappings of math teaching. One section of the talk dealt with asking the simple question "about how much?" with a expression containing some oddball square roots.

At random around 11pm one night, that point resurfaced. A weakness I've noticed for a while is that students lack an understanding for the value of things like sqrt(2) or how you could use what you know to approximate sqrt(27). Or the value of 3/2 or how to estimate 1/3 of something. I had a conversation with another student once about the final price for a car, and they had no idea about how to approximate tax/title/license on top. After explaining it, they ask the poignant question "why does no one mention this in school?"

This year I think I'll do something about it. It's like a really focused version of Estimation 180 without all the pictures. I'm thinking I pose four situations a day and have a discussion about how these could be approximated to build their "oddball" number sense.

I probably wouldn't type them all in advance, this was an exploration exercise. Probably after a few months I could compile them here for those of you that would like a home version.

This could be fun. If you too have noticed a deficiency in number sense, don't complain about it or blame calculators, try to do something.

AuthorJonathan Claydon
3 CommentsPost a comment

My classroom is my eternal playground. Some highlights of this year's version.

The teacher space is tiny. There are 36 kids in here at certain points of the day, and they need the space more than I do. My first year my teacher desk was 1000% bigger than this. A class of 25 was also mind blowingly huge at the time. The device cabinet has moved over here and the landing zone for kid things like pencil sharpeners and tissues.

There's seating for six at every group now. I developed some emergency plans in case that's not enough. The back of the room is a lot more efficient. One of those TVs used to float out in the middle of the room which was a pain to walk around. I'm hoping it's not too cramped in the little rows between the tables.

I had notebook in two spots last year because there used to be some other things on this table. Whatever junk it was is gone so all the books should fit over here without an issue.

I organized the supply table a little more. The glue sticks are in a container for dishwasher pods. Every table has some scissors is former pineapple containers. The bonus was all the pineapple I got to eat to acquire these containers. No more staplers, they all got broken. RIP all the staplers.

I am extraordinarily pumped for this school year.

AuthorJonathan Claydon

Prior to the start of school, I stumbled on this sign (not on my campus):


Further up there is a diagram showing exactly how the cabinet is supposed to appear. Now, look, this isn't intended to call this person out and tell them they're doing it wrong or anything like that. And I'll be the first to tell you that I'm not strict about much. Chances are there were a series of incidents that lead to this sign and intervention was necessary. I have a serious face too. But, how you react to this sign could be an interesting indicator of your classroom culture.

To me, a sign like this is an immediate sign of mistrust. You, dear child, are GOING to screw up and I WILL catch you.

I have a lot of devices in my room. Being the control lover that I am, I too appreciate a nicely organized cabinet. When I ask for them back, I get them back. The kids make a stack on a table. We use them often enough they know how this works. Then I stick them back in the cabinet. No boxed threats required.

Students are not by nature against you. You can make a lot of progress if you recognize that they can be trusted individuals with something to offer.

AuthorJonathan Claydon
3 CommentsPost a comment

As my iPad set grew, charging them started to become a problem. We have a cart to store them in that has a few power strips and some dedicated USB chargers. There are only so many outlets to go around, so I couldn't use all the stock chargers. I had a set of 10 and had to do charging in shifts. It made the cabinet a mess. The dedicated USB chargers are underpowered for their task (10W, 0.5A shared among 4 ports, a full size iPad draws 12W on its own), and when the cart is loaded up, they can't sustain enough juice for an iPad (a string of ding-ding-ding noises as the iPad gains and loses power).

Enter this bad boy.


These are 5-port, 40W, 8A chargers by Anker. They cost $25 each and I bought 5. These have the juice necessary to power a ton of devices and let me get rid of the mountain of power chargers cluttering up the cabinet.

After some sharpie labeling and cable snaking, here they are installed:

The body is coated in rubber, so mounting them to the side with a velcro patch didn't really work out, but this is ok. When outputting full power they get very warm (VERY warm), so they need some air to breathe. I plugged in 20 devices and heard none of the ding-ding-ding problems from the underpowered chargers. Plus, look at all these adapters I don't have to use:

As a bonus, I used the fifth one to solve a nagging problem I had last year. With the prevalence of cell phones (I can hear you now OMG CELLPHONES HATE HATE HATE, but calm down a bit), my outlets would get commandeered whether I granted permission or not. Often it was at the expense of the pencil sharpener or some other critical thing.

Sitting on the top of the cart is my solution, a phone charging station. Charge it here, stop touching my outlets. 

The reduction of cabinet clutter is fantastic. There were three power strips in that thing, all plugged into each other (super safe guys). Now it's only one.

AuthorJonathan Claydon
3 CommentsPost a comment

This was detailed over a year ago, but a lot changes. A refreshed look at how you can make a whole fleet of iPad devices communicate together and offer students a universal experience.

Before starting, updating the software to the latest version of iOS wouldn't hurt. Everything but an original iPad can run iOS 7.1.2 (current) and will be able to run iOS 8. When iOS 8 arrives in the fall, I won't update my devices until it's time for regular maintenance over winter break.

App Store

You may have done this already when setting up the device. It asks for an Apple ID at the start. If you're inheriting devices or weren't the one who took it out of the box, you'll want to sign in your account here. Use an e-mail address separate from any personal Apple ID you use. Every device you sign in with the account will able to access the same batch of purchases.

Disabling automatic downloads will prevent student devices from grabbing copies of things you may not be ready to deploy yet. Enabling Auto Updates will apply updates as they become available, preventing you from manually applying them on every device.

Acquire purchases by launching the App Store from the home screen and finding the "Purchased" button on the bottom right.


You shouldn't have to do anything extra. By signing in to the App Store with your Apple ID, it should appear here as well. It's also possible this was entered at set up. Again, if you're inheriting a device or did not set it up initially, you'll want to check here. Notice most of the features are disabled. The Safari features let each device share a common pool of bookmarks, it also enables one device to see what tabs are open on others. To enable the kind of fun photo discussions I've done in class, you'll want the photo feature enabled. This allows devices to contribute to a common photo pool. Photos actively in the shared pool appear by going to Photos > Albums > My Photo Stream.

Google Drive

You'll first need the Google Drive app from the App Store. I use Google Drive to accomplish another type of classwork sharing. Every device is signed in to an account I made specifically for this purpose. If your school e-mail is tied to a large scale Google Apps for Education deployment like mine is, you won't want to use that. In theory you can ask students to sign in to their own Google Accounts here if they have them, but this is less fiddly.


Students will distract themselves no matter what, but a few options in the restrictions screen will prevent them from doing any real damage (like deleting an app). When you first tap Enable Restrictions you'll be ask to set a passcode. This is different from a passcode to unlock the device. After restrictions are enabled, you will need this passcode to make changes.

I disable a lot of features. All of the iTunes and App Store related ones will remove the icon from the home screen. If you enabled Auto Updates as mentioned previously, they will run with the App Store hidden. If you choose not to do Auto Updates, you'll need to come back to the restrictions screen and flip the switch any time you want to check for updates. Without the icon present, you'll never know they exist.

Towards the bottom of the Restrictions screen are options for Twitter, Facebook, and Accounts. In each case you'll want to disable the ability to make changes. Since you can't delete the Mail app or Messages app, you'll want them to be nonfunctional if a student attempts to open them. When properly set, Mail and Messages will display the error above. Hitting OK drops back to the Home Screen.


No need for computer based syncing, no need for backups, and no need for any crazy apps. My devices are designed to be clones of one another that allow any work created to be offloaded quickly.

More importantly, with iCloud and Google Drive, students get a chance to talk about what others are creating. iPads shouldn't be expensive workbooks.

AuthorJonathan Claydon
2 CommentsPost a comment

During a Calculus workshop I attended, the primary purpose was to run everyone through the curriculum in four days, discussing common student pit falls along the way. It gave me a very new perspective on the class and made it seem so much simpler than it felt 12 years ago. Then I went a reworked the free response questions 18 year old me faced and it was stupid simple.

But, throughout it was assumed that we all knew how to structure the class. Quizzes, tests, and piles of homework done on notebook paper. How anyone decided that was the "standard" way of conducting a class was beyond me. And something I've always wondered, is that the working assumption when studying education in college? I wasn't an education major, but it seems like all the ones I meet just KNOW that you give quizzes, tests, and a pile of homework done on notebook paper. And points. You must be VERY fiddly about points.

Here are my goals for Calculus:

  • homework will be involved, a bit
  • frequent assessment is necessary
  • exposure to the AP format is necessary
  • conceptual understanding is HUGE
  • similar to Algebra II, some foundational skills must persist all year

How I'm going to attempt to implement those goals:


It's got to happen, really just for some persistent exposure. I have no intent on burying them in it, and will try to make sure the assignments are short and have purpose. Initially I was thinking one notebook for notes and another for homework, but forget it, let's just put it all in one place and if they need new ones in the spring, they need new ones in the spring.


Calculus is such a small set of skills when you sit down and look at it. Isolating them into a good SBG list is a little difficult. Plus, with an AP crowd, I don't want them to become dependent on reassessment, a common issue with high level students and SBG. The prevailing idea is to keep assessments frequent: every 7 - 10 calendar days. However, there will be two skills section and one conceptual section, each assessed holistically (probably each section rated between 0 - 5). No fiddly points. I don't think letting them use notebooks on the assessment will help my cause. These are the kids who are really going to have to learn to stand on their own in the face of mediocre college instruction.

Skills can be reassessed whenever. Conceptual not so much. There won't be any built-in replacement, just a series of skills marks accumulated during the grading period (they can be altered by coming after school and trying again). I think I know what this looks like when recorded in a notebook, but I'll wait to see it in person before I share.

The big twist will be a six weeks exam. Something that's existed in our Calculus classes for a couple years. Though I want it to reflect AP format a little better from an appearance and time point of view. In 40 minutes, it's roughly 9 multiple choice questions and a free response question, graded according to AP standards.


The major diversion from my traditional SBG skill system is to allow myself options. Maybe I want to throw in some product rule and quotient rule months after we covered it? Maybe I want to throw in some trig equations? Through the generic heading of "skills" I establish the ability to dig through the whole back catalog. Learning derivative rules in October is great but they need to stick around until April. Everything in the curriculum has to matter.

Our Calculus trainer implemented this through daily pop quizzes. Anything is on the table for these. I don't agree with that method, but the idea has merit.

Confidence is really the enemy here. For whatever reason, our Calculus students buckle under the pressure. I'm hoping frequent exposure to the AP format and forcing them to commit certain things to the deep layers of their memory will help them feel good walking into that exam.

AuthorJonathan Claydon
3 CommentsPost a comment